Well, I send them my photo of the coin, and they said they'd take my return. cool!
Awesome! Yeah I had the same problem with a coin I bought on eBay. Looked BU in pictures but arrived at my house XF and cleaned. I don't know why sellers do this because they get many returns. Maybe they are just waiting for someone who keeps it. Anyways, I ended up just buying a nice red indian from a member here. I've never been wronged while buying on CCF!