Just curious here. WE know it's an 1846 N-19. Would the rev die marker be enough for NGC or PCGS to put the date on the slab? I'm not suggesting this SHOULD be slabbed (because I actually don't), but I'm just wondering if they would .
Quote: the tell is the lines above the E in AMERICA.
Awww that's what it is! I figured if someone was able to attribute this by memory, the coin most likely has a unique feature. I spent too long looking at this coin in class and couldn't find the feature. Thanks for the challenge!