| Author |
 Topic  |
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
6398 Posts |
I certainly have developed over time the same understanding of the PCGS wizards approach to these seldom seen (by them) circulated commemoratives. Their opinions are simply inconsistent and, as pointed out, each type coin example resets the grading standards. After approximately 10 years now pursuing these coins I humbly believe that I have developed a better overall judgement across the entire series than the wizards have. Quote:
David's Texas examples in his thread "Update 4" show an egregious error on PCGS's part between those 2 coins I appreciate the empathy ... but the fact is that it is an expensive, frustrating and time consuming game to play crack out and resubmit .... so that 1934 Texas remains in my set judged by the wizards as AG03. Quote:
here's a small lot of coins off eBay Fantastic lot indeed ... I've never to my recollection came across one like that. If I were to grade them (by the photos provided) ... my judgement would be as follows: Lexington: G06 Pilgrim (1920): AG03/G04 borderline W-C (1952): AG03 |
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
688 Posts |
Quote:
...but the fact is that it is an expensive, frustrating and time consuming game to play crack out and resubmit The wizards know the power of The Hobby(tm) quite well! Can't argue with the grades you assigned to each of those   
PCGS submissions 2005-2018. Mailings(21) Orders(43) / 249 coin attempts. 12 Fails(5%) / Member vouchers(19%) Economy(62%) Regular(13%) Free(3%) Express(3%) / Barber 50c (46%) Classic Commemorative (38%) Hawaii(3%) SCD (6%) Other(3%)/ Fails: Cleaned(2) Alt surfaces(1) Scratch(1) Damage(1) "86"(3) 2 Columbian & 1 BTW; Min Grade(2) DNC(2)-Same coin NGC XF40 Barber 50c. Express fees paid by seller (cross guarantee). Kept the coin & later submitted raw: PCGS XF40 [eyeroll] Fails: Econ(8) Regular(2) Express(2)/// Other TPGs: ICG (2011-2018): 35/35 NGC: 0 ANACS: 0
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
688 Posts |
PCGS submissions 2005-2018. Mailings(21) Orders(43) / 249 coin attempts. 12 Fails(5%) / Member vouchers(19%) Economy(62%) Regular(13%) Free(3%) Express(3%) / Barber 50c (46%) Classic Commemorative (38%) Hawaii(3%) SCD (6%) Other(3%)/ Fails: Cleaned(2) Alt surfaces(1) Scratch(1) Damage(1) "86"(3) 2 Columbian & 1 BTW; Min Grade(2) DNC(2)-Same coin NGC XF40 Barber 50c. Express fees paid by seller (cross guarantee). Kept the coin & later submitted raw: PCGS XF40 [eyeroll] Fails: Econ(8) Regular(2) Express(2)/// Other TPGs: ICG (2011-2018): 35/35 NGC: 0 ANACS: 0
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
688 Posts |
PCGS submissions 2005-2018. Mailings(21) Orders(43) / 249 coin attempts. 12 Fails(5%) / Member vouchers(19%) Economy(62%) Regular(13%) Free(3%) Express(3%) / Barber 50c (46%) Classic Commemorative (38%) Hawaii(3%) SCD (6%) Other(3%)/ Fails: Cleaned(2) Alt surfaces(1) Scratch(1) Damage(1) "86"(3) 2 Columbian & 1 BTW; Min Grade(2) DNC(2)-Same coin NGC XF40 Barber 50c. Express fees paid by seller (cross guarantee). Kept the coin & later submitted raw: PCGS XF40 [eyeroll] Fails: Econ(8) Regular(2) Express(2)/// Other TPGs: ICG (2011-2018): 35/35 NGC: 0 ANACS: 0
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
688 Posts |
Any grade guesses on the Stone Mountains? Lafayette? Izzy? No cheating  PCGS submissions 2005-2018. Mailings(21) Orders(43) / 249 coin attempts. 12 Fails(5%) / Member vouchers(19%) Economy(62%) Regular(13%) Free(3%) Express(3%) / Barber 50c (46%) Classic Commemorative (38%) Hawaii(3%) SCD (6%) Other(3%)/ Fails: Cleaned(2) Alt surfaces(1) Scratch(1) Damage(1) "86"(3) 2 Columbian & 1 BTW; Min Grade(2) DNC(2)-Same coin NGC XF40 Barber 50c. Express fees paid by seller (cross guarantee). Kept the coin & later submitted raw: PCGS XF40 [eyeroll] Fails: Econ(8) Regular(2) Express(2)/// Other TPGs: ICG (2011-2018): 35/35 NGC: 0 ANACS: 0
Edited by two_tonevf35
03/10/2018 3:01 pm
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
6398 Posts |
Indeed ... I'll offer opinions based on the photos provided ... not sure how I could 'cheat' as suggested by the OP. Both Stone Mountain are AG03 today ... original surfaces and certifiable. They might have been judged FR02 in the early days of submitting these to the wizards ... absolutely certain neither is PO01. The Lafayette is VF25/VF30 ... again original surfaces. Lovely example. The Isabella is VG08/VG10 ... crusty but original and certifiable. That is how I would grade them based on the photos provided ... what say you on the wizards opinions? Take a look at my other hobby ... http://www.finewoodcrafter.comToo many hobbies .... too much work .... not enough time. |
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
688 Posts |
It can be challenging to grade from photos and I appreciate David's willingness to take a stab at these old friends! (Good, I will not reveal the secret as to how some 'cheat' with the GTG, although I did attempt the usual means and it seems formatting on posting photos here does not allow it!) OK for the grades decreed by PCGS.... Stone Mountain on top: AG3 Stone Mountain below: FR2 Lafayette: F12 Izzy: VF25 I can't find the slab photos for the Izzy:    PCGS submissions 2005-2018. Mailings(21) Orders(43) / 249 coin attempts. 12 Fails(5%) / Member vouchers(19%) Economy(62%) Regular(13%) Free(3%) Express(3%) / Barber 50c (46%) Classic Commemorative (38%) Hawaii(3%) SCD (6%) Other(3%)/ Fails: Cleaned(2) Alt surfaces(1) Scratch(1) Damage(1) "86"(3) 2 Columbian & 1 BTW; Min Grade(2) DNC(2)-Same coin NGC XF40 Barber 50c. Express fees paid by seller (cross guarantee). Kept the coin & later submitted raw: PCGS XF40 [eyeroll] Fails: Econ(8) Regular(2) Express(2)/// Other TPGs: ICG (2011-2018): 35/35 NGC: 0 ANACS: 0
Edited by two_tonevf35
03/11/2018 4:50 pm
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
688 Posts |
PCGS submissions 2005-2018. Mailings(21) Orders(43) / 249 coin attempts. 12 Fails(5%) / Member vouchers(19%) Economy(62%) Regular(13%) Free(3%) Express(3%) / Barber 50c (46%) Classic Commemorative (38%) Hawaii(3%) SCD (6%) Other(3%)/ Fails: Cleaned(2) Alt surfaces(1) Scratch(1) Damage(1) "86"(3) 2 Columbian & 1 BTW; Min Grade(2) DNC(2)-Same coin NGC XF40 Barber 50c. Express fees paid by seller (cross guarantee). Kept the coin & later submitted raw: PCGS XF40 [eyeroll] Fails: Econ(8) Regular(2) Express(2)/// Other TPGs: ICG (2011-2018): 35/35 NGC: 0 ANACS: 0
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
688 Posts |
 Answer: PCGS VF35
PCGS submissions 2005-2018. Mailings(21) Orders(43) / 249 coin attempts. 12 Fails(5%) / Member vouchers(19%) Economy(62%) Regular(13%) Free(3%) Express(3%) / Barber 50c (46%) Classic Commemorative (38%) Hawaii(3%) SCD (6%) Other(3%)/ Fails: Cleaned(2) Alt surfaces(1) Scratch(1) Damage(1) "86"(3) 2 Columbian & 1 BTW; Min Grade(2) DNC(2)-Same coin NGC XF40 Barber 50c. Express fees paid by seller (cross guarantee). Kept the coin & later submitted raw: PCGS XF40 [eyeroll] Fails: Econ(8) Regular(2) Express(2)/// Other TPGs: ICG (2011-2018): 35/35 NGC: 0 ANACS: 0
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
688 Posts |
Pat Braddick provenance -a personal favorite. I think he angled the slabs so the scanner would focus- that was an old trick anyways if blurring scans were a problem. So I rotated and cropped them to fit the 300K here.   PCGS submissions 2005-2018. Mailings(21) Orders(43) / 249 coin attempts. 12 Fails(5%) / Member vouchers(19%) Economy(62%) Regular(13%) Free(3%) Express(3%) / Barber 50c (46%) Classic Commemorative (38%) Hawaii(3%) SCD (6%) Other(3%)/ Fails: Cleaned(2) Alt surfaces(1) Scratch(1) Damage(1) "86"(3) 2 Columbian & 1 BTW; Min Grade(2) DNC(2)-Same coin NGC XF40 Barber 50c. Express fees paid by seller (cross guarantee). Kept the coin & later submitted raw: PCGS XF40 [eyeroll] Fails: Econ(8) Regular(2) Express(2)/// Other TPGs: ICG (2011-2018): 35/35 NGC: 0 ANACS: 0
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
6398 Posts |
I failed the grading test ... LOL. Remain interested in whatever else you have to contribute. David |
|
Moderator
United States
60341 Posts |
Wonderful continued contributions, two_tonevf35. |
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
688 Posts |
David, I would NOT call that a failure, sir! Let me what I can dig up tonight from the archives.
@jbuck, glad you are enjoying as well, and coming from a Mod, that means alot!
PCGS submissions 2005-2018. Mailings(21) Orders(43) / 249 coin attempts. 12 Fails(5%) / Member vouchers(19%) Economy(62%) Regular(13%) Free(3%) Express(3%) / Barber 50c (46%) Classic Commemorative (38%) Hawaii(3%) SCD (6%) Other(3%)/ Fails: Cleaned(2) Alt surfaces(1) Scratch(1) Damage(1) "86"(3) 2 Columbian & 1 BTW; Min Grade(2) DNC(2)-Same coin NGC XF40 Barber 50c. Express fees paid by seller (cross guarantee). Kept the coin & later submitted raw: PCGS XF40 [eyeroll] Fails: Econ(8) Regular(2) Express(2)/// Other TPGs: ICG (2011-2018): 35/35 NGC: 0 ANACS: 0
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
688 Posts |
Here you go, David. I found this one raw. Your images on the Registry are superior  PCGS submissions 2005-2018. Mailings(21) Orders(43) / 249 coin attempts. 12 Fails(5%) / Member vouchers(19%) Economy(62%) Regular(13%) Free(3%) Express(3%) / Barber 50c (46%) Classic Commemorative (38%) Hawaii(3%) SCD (6%) Other(3%)/ Fails: Cleaned(2) Alt surfaces(1) Scratch(1) Damage(1) "86"(3) 2 Columbian & 1 BTW; Min Grade(2) DNC(2)-Same coin NGC XF40 Barber 50c. Express fees paid by seller (cross guarantee). Kept the coin & later submitted raw: PCGS XF40 [eyeroll] Fails: Econ(8) Regular(2) Express(2)/// Other TPGs: ICG (2011-2018): 35/35 NGC: 0 ANACS: 0
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
6398 Posts |
Outstanding .... I suggested above that one of my current examples has its pedigree attributed to your collecting eye. Good to know that for sure however. Same coin:  I acquired the coin on eBay in March 2014. Wondering how many collectors it passed through from you to me? It is certainly a reminder that all of us have temporary possession of the coins in our collections. |
|
Topic |
|
Posted 03/08/2018 11:51 pm
