Hello wideglide, I like Indian cents. This one makes VG. Not sure if the surfaces are original.
I think your getting a little flack because you didn't put anything in your title about wanting a grade opinion or thoughts etc. This is a low value coin and I think some are being a little snooty. Make a title that reads "Seeking opinions on my 1905 IHC!" It will give people an idea of what you are after.