This arrived in the mail today and I'm quite happy with it. It wasn't a cherrypick but a correctly labeled coin, and I'm optimistic that it's more or less AU.
These may or may not be rare. They are nearly impossible to see on circulated coins and/or in images for cherrypicking so maybe there are more of them out there than we think. But for now it's a tough one to add to a collection.
1930-D/D Lincoln Wheat cent