I was reexamining a coin I got back from grading a month or so ago. When I first got it back I was just disappointed with grading and stuck it in a draw... But now looking over, I feel like it was under-graded. Coin has nice luster... and I think the details on the obverse hair and reverse chest... as well as the cleanness of the fields warrants a grade higher than AU55.
Curious what others think... and def appreciate peoples input on whether they would 1) Accept Grade or 2) Submit for Regrade
I would not resubmit this coin. I think AU55 is quite accurate. The obverse counts for 80% of total grade and there seems to be quite a bit of rubbing along the hair above the ear and also the hat at the back of the head. I have seen fields with more scratches and dings on an MS64 but this isn't the only attribute that is judged. Please refer to the PCGS Photograde pages online.