Looks like the grades are good on the first two dollars I think AU58 is a tad high, more like AU53. You will find that ICG in general brings a considerably less amount than PCGS
or NGC, unless the dealer is buying the coin and not the holder, which honestly they won't be on these coins most likely. My friend from high school (Keith Love) started ICG which at the time was a great idea, the other two TPG
's NGC and PCGS
tended to give their regular big clients better grades on borderline coins, Keith's idea was by having a third party company remove all indicators or ownership on the coins there would be less of a chance to grade better for one individual over another. He sold the company a couple of years ago, I was an early client, though haven't used them in a long time, though I always look at coins in ICG holders for potential purchases, as so many dealers pass them up in lieu of PCGS
, NGS and ANCS in that order it seems. There are some great deals in ICG holdered coins out there.
"Buy the Book Before You Buy the Coin" - Aaron R. Feldman ANA
Life Member #3288 in good standing since 1982 • 2¢ variety collector.