LC-61 Is it or isn't it ?
I started filling holes in Whitman 1 cent and 5 cent folders back in the late 50's (YIKES), then US 1 and 5 cents, then all Canadian decimal (yikes again).
Before 2000 I had exactly 0 Cdn. colonial tokens, so when I saw how many there were and how cheap you could get many of them on
ebay, I lost control. I had seen this token in Charlton Millennium issue when I starting scouring
ebay for coins and then tokens in 2000.
I had won a lot of lots on
ebay, including Cdn. colonial tokens, many 1700's British halfpennies and forgeries when I came across this token. It fit in with what I collected and it was another Abe Lincoln cost coin so (all together now), "Why not?". I knew about the question of Canadian or not.
It didn't matter to me if it was considered Canadian or not, it was in the book so it was like a hole to fill. When I saw one posted here recently, I, of course, had to go check mine. Sure enough, legends. I also looked in the Charlton catalogue to see what was written. Yep, no legends allowed.

On the obverse of my token, I saw damage that looks like a small hammer mark, an oval with a blob in it. And then I looked at the Charlton 2020 token catalogue - Is it considered a genuine Canadian one ? Have a look in front of the king's face in the Charlton photo. It has the same oval mark, with what looks like a cross in it. Same die ? Same clash (although nothing on the reverse matches that) ?

