Spink lists this coin in VF at £10. ( No F listing for this coin ). Comparing Spink prices with small local dealers I find prices to be around 50% to 75% of Spink's. Quite often I find boxes of old pennies of F or lower for just a few pence.
I would agree at somewhere around F to VF for your coin, making it a reasonable deal if bought here in the UK. Are UK coins more expensive in the US because they are out of their home country and possibly harder to find?