| Author |
Topic  |
Ancientnoob
Pillar Of The Community
United States
2313 Posts
|
Hello All, This piece is a little out of my collection sphere. I was wondering if someone could comment on my coin here. Maybe tell me a little more about it. It was purchesed as authentic. I bought it not because I collect this ruler but the portiture of the George III was quite remarkable. Could someone give me a grade on this, is it ok to handle like an Ancient coin. What is it worth. The coin is silver and 5.98 grams. Comment regardless is always appreciated.
Thanks, Nate
 Non plaudite. Modo pecuniam jacite.
|
|
|
|
Pillar Of The Community
United Kingdom
1913 Posts |
Modern coins are supposed to not be handled I hear, and this falls under modern. To be honest, it's yours now. You can handle it if you please.
however, this is a really nice one...Id call it a presentation piece.
As for information, all kings and queens model themselves after the romans - this is old George as Caesar. Latin wording, structure, Vs for Us and etc. I suppose he thought it would make him more powerful. In short, it makes a great thing to put next to roman coins to show the romans lasting influence.
Help Support My Education - Visit my eBay Listings for Roman Coins!
|
|
Valued Member
United Kingdom
178 Posts |
Re the inscriptions:
On the obverse
GEORGIVS III / DEI GRATIA
"George the 3rd, by the Grace of God"
On the Reverse
M. B. F. ET H. REX, F. D. B. ET L. D. S. R. I. AT. ET E.
Magnae Brittaniae, Franciae et Hiberniae Rex, Fidei Defensor, Brunswickensis et Luneburgensis Dux, Sancti Romani Imperii Archithesaurarius et Elector
"Of Great Britain, France and Ireland King, defender of the faith, of Brunswick and Luneburg Duke, of the Holy Roman Empire Archtreasurer and Elector".
A proud boast indeed. English monarchs still fancied themselves as kings of France, harking back to the mediaeval times. At the 3 o'clock position on the reverse are the arms of France, 6 o'clock Ireland, 9 o'clock arms of the German possessions Brunswick. Luneburg and Hanover ( Hannover ), at 12 o'clock halved arms of England and Scotland.
Your coin is the more common of the shillings, as shown by the dot above the king's head. There was also a version with small hearts in the top corners of the German shield.
It is in superb condition. Thanks for sharing the photographs.
Can't give you catalogue values at this time as am at work. Later I will add them. If it is not a rude question, how much did you pay?
|
|
Pillar Of The Community
United States
2313 Posts |
I paid about a hundred US. (I hope I got a deal) Thanks for the help, I was just so struck by it. No pun intended. I dont know much about them but I love coins and would like to branch out a little bit. I know george bungled the americas for the crown. Thanks again. Nate Btw does anyone know about how many of this year were minted. Is there an accepted population number for these. ( I would be happy with estimates)
Non plaudite. Modo pecuniam jacite.
Edited by Ancientnoob 07/30/2012 01:19 am
|
|
Pillar Of The Community
United Kingdom
1913 Posts |
$100 dollars seems to be a bit on the high side - however, your's is in exeptional condition. eBay might have given you a cheaper one (well, the UK eBay is bound to be cheaper for UK currency.)
Help Support My Education - Visit my eBay Listings for Roman Coins!
|
|
Pillar Of The Community
Australia
2691 Posts |
quote: "I know george bungled the americas for the crown." - huh ?
quote: "the UK eBay is bound to be cheaper for UK currency." - I disagree. There is a greater supply of U.K. coins in the U.K., but the demand for them is greatest in the U.K. American coins are most expensive in America, and French coins in France.
I agree with Anaximander: you've got a particularly nice example of an early shilling. The dimensions were altered in the Great Recoinage of 1816. $100 is a top price, but not excessive.
I have a gold-plated 1787 shilling: they were very similar size to the Guinea, and had a passing similarity in appearance, so I'm guessing that mine was intended to be "passed off" as a gold coin.
"the only people who are not confused are those who are not paying attention."
|
|
Pillar Of The Community
United States
2313 Posts |
@Peter Thomas - Thats coo,l a gold plated shilling. I take it your shilling was plated in the 18th century and used as a counterfeit? In response to your, "huh?" I found this excerpt that better summarizes what I was trying to briefly say.
''George III hoped that "the tongue of malice may not paint my intentions in those colours she admires, nor the sycophant extoll me beyond what I deserve",[117] but in the popular mind George III has been both demonised and praised. While very popular at the start of his reign, by the mid-1770s George had lost the loyalty of revolutionary American colonists,[118] though it has been estimated that as many as half of the colonists remained loyal.[119] The grievances in the United States Declaration of Independence were presented as "repeated injuries and usurpations" that he had committed to establish an "absolute Tyranny" over the colonies. The Declaration's wording has contributed to the American public's perception of George as a tyrant''
I never like paying more then something is worth. I am glad I still got a good deal. Thanks for your comments guys. I am glad I was able to get a "top?" example :-)
Nate
Non plaudite. Modo pecuniam jacite.
|
|
Valued Member
United Kingdom
336 Posts |
Hi It is a very common coin.The previous shilling was 1758(very,very common)In 1763 the Northumberland shilling was produced.This is a rare coin which the Chinese have picked up on...tread carefully with this one 70% on eBay are fakes. 1 wouldn't pay more than £40/50 for your coin as they sit in every British dealers trays who can't shift them.
|
|
Pillar Of The Community
United States
2313 Posts |
If its only worth 50 pounds. I guess I over paid. Although I Have never met a UK dealer, we have nobe in the US. I also have never seen this " common" coin before I bought it. I never have luck importing from the UK either. So figure 800 USD for a plane ticket, I think I did alright. Are these exclusivly preserved in high grades? I am surprised that every UK dealers got one. I am sure now there has got to be a fair amount of fakes out there. Thanks for commenting all.
Non plaudite. Modo pecuniam jacite.
Edited by Ancientnoob 07/30/2012 4:03 pm
|
|
Pillar Of The Community
United Kingdom
1913 Posts |
Ancient noob, unlike America, a lot of British coinage is preserved in peoples homes. People find purses full of old money around. when my great gran copped it, we found loads of predecimal currency from back to 1775 just around and about. I had a look yesterday in my foreign and old coin pot and found a silver 3p and a whole load of old pennies.
Basically, all the coinage in England of the newer variety (pre-decimal after about 1750) is plentiful. Heck, go metal detecting and you'll find pennies from 1802 and think nothing of it. A coin from 1802 in America is a big deal, but its not so here.
Help Support My Education - Visit my eBay Listings for Roman Coins!
|
|
Valued Member
United Kingdom
178 Posts |
Ancientnoob: To answer your query if they are only preserved in high grades -I have one I would rate as F ( VF if I screw my eyes half shut and hold it up against the sun ).
Spink catalogues your coin as VF £60 and EF £135. This is assuming your coin is genuine. It might be plentiful in London, but out in the sticks where I am, you don't see much silver pre 1816.
I am pleased to own this coin because apart from the 1763 Northumberland shilling ( rare and often faked ) and the 1798 "Dorrien and Magens" ( extremely rare ) it is the only George III shilling pre the great recoinage of 1816. It is probably the only shilling from this era an ordinary collector like me will ever get.
|
|
Pillar Of The Community
United States
2313 Posts |
Thanks, assuming its real, do you think it would grade EF?
Non plaudite. Modo pecuniam jacite.
|
|
Valued Member
United Kingdom
349 Posts |
>>1 wouldn't pay more than £40/50 for your coin as they sit in every British dealers trays who can't shift them.
$100 is £64, so the price is quite reasonable. It is somewhat better than those that sit unsold in trays, or at least the trays I frequent :)
As for grade GVF ? (which probably crosses over to a US EF ?)
|
|
Pillar Of The Community
Australia
2691 Posts |
"go metal detecting and you'll find pennies from 1802 and think nothing of it." - if you have any to spare, please let me know.
Ancientnoob: my shilling is a variety of counterfeit, but, at its heart, remains "genuine". KG3 was a constitutional monarch. American greivances arose from decisions made by politicians in the British Parliament. British kings ignore Parliament at their peril (examples: Charles I, executed 1649; James II chased into exile 1689). The pollies shifted the blame to KG3, and American historians have bought the lie for more than 200 years.
"the only people who are not confused are those who are not paying attention."
|
|
Pillar Of The Community
United States
2313 Posts |
@ALL thanks all for coming out and taking a look and commenting on my coin. Thanks for the quick history lesson. I assure you all that American Historian have most likely got a lot wrong. Maybe more then what is correct. Again thanks all.
Nate
Non plaudite. Modo pecuniam jacite.
|
|
Valued Member
United Kingdom
336 Posts |
Ignore Spink prices,they are a guide only. Ebay,fairs,auctions,dealers lists are the current selling prices.Spink is way out (up and down) on many coins.
|
Topic  |
|