Opinions Needed

I must apologize here because I about couldn't stop laughing long enough to respond as soon as I saw his photos and then yours of the coin sent. That is definitely not the same coin and well if it is, he is better at photographing coins than you are because he made that worn out thing look like it had allot more detail. Must be the lighting he used...
I hope you all know I am kidding about the lighting because there is no way anyone could make that coin he received look like the one sellers picture no matter what type of lights you used

The seller now has 91 items listed about 35 more then 2 days ago so I know the seller is looking at his E-Bay page. But still no response as to where the listed coin went too. I think I will end up just getting my money back and not the coin he had listed .

Yeah, this one's so far off the mark that it would be my leaning to give the seller the benefit of the doubt for an honest mistake. Stuff happens.

twohawks, you have been more than patient and there is no reason for him not to reply to you within 24 hours. Anything over that is unacceptable. I would file with ebay and get your refund. Reward him with a NEG feedback and put him on your do not buy from list.

WOW I just got the sellers reply..... What Bull
He states that the listing was for a similar type. I have looked over his listing a few times, and this just keeps looking like just a "if you don't catch me" type seller.

Here is the 2nd e-mail I sent and his response as well my second reply.

Dear luckyfish1,

This sale was and is listed as the coin, not a sellers choice of a simalar idem. I have saved the listing no where in it is it stated the seller can or will change the idem. Anyway I do not what this coin as it is not the one in your listing. I will have it in the mail back to you Monday morning by 8:45 AM EST.


- collectorscorner-coins




--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
From: luckyfish1
To: collectorscorner-coins
Subject: Re: Other: collectorscorner-coins sent a message about 1889o Morgan dollar #300725834409
Sent Date: Jun-24-12 16:11:25 PDT


<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
Dear collectorscorner-coins,

Hell-o, sorry I haven't gotten back with you before now but I have been out of town playing in a golf tournament. FYI, this was listed as "sell similar item with no returns accepted", however if you would like to keep it I will entertain an equitable offer to save time and the hassel and delaying getting your money back, if not return the coin and upon receipt I will gladly refund your money. Thanks, elf


- luckyfish1




--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
From: collectorscorner-coins
To: luckyfish1
Subject: Other: collectorscorner-coins sent a message about 1889o Morgan dollar #300725834409
Sent Date: Jun-24-12 08:58:32 PDT


Dear luckyfish1,

I am sure that this is not the same coin in the listing I won. I do not know if it is a shipping error, but no contact is making me think it was not an error.

Here is a link to your listing photo and photos of the coin you shipped me. https://goccf.com/t/122316


- collectorscorner-coins


1889o Morgan dollar
Item Id: 300725834409
End time: Jun-14-12 17:57:02 PDT
Buyer:
collectorscorner-coins (54)
100.0% Positive Feedback
Member since Jan-09-12 in United States
Location: OH, United States

Listing Status: This message was sent while the listing was closed.

I hope you gave him negative feedback for all the trouble you went through.

RUSS, I am glad things worked out for you in this matter, Be Well and cautious, LOL.....Mike