What Should I Pay For XF And AU Morgans?

16 each based on those pics.

I would pay 17 to 18 for each coin based on your sample pictures

I wouldn't even bother especially if I were in your position. You're working on completing an MS64 Morgan set in PL condition. How do these fit in your collection?

So I went to meet the guy. He told me two different stories over the last four days where the coins came from. One time he said he bought them from dealers when he tried to collect, today it was from various flea markets and garage sales. All of them were just like the photos. Nothing special, all commons. He would not move off the prices he had on the two by twos. When I try to show him that even in the grades he had listed the coins were not even close on price sheets. He obviously graded and priced them himself. I politely said sorry I will have to pass. He flipped out, started cursing, calling names etc. I guess he overpaid and was trying to recover his money. On my way out the door he screamed from his window and said that I was hurting for money and try to lie to get the coins from him for nothing. Lol. I just ignored him. So, I won't be doing that again ha ha

They also often do that when caught in a lie.

Unfortunately this kind of experience with the non-collecting general public isn't uncommon.

I'll throw in my Two Cents as well. I buy all Morgans and Peace dollars at $18 to $20 each at the shop. That's for common date coins G to MS. I probably buy 60 to 70 a week at that price. I sell at $25 each, except for the Home run coins. Also the premiums have come waaaaaaay down on Morgans on ebay. Coins that I was selling for $40 to $55 6 months ago are lucky to bring $30 to $35 now. Talking to other dealers reveals much the same for them as well. Good Luck!