Real Stinker Of An ICCS Grade. Anyone Else Ever Experienced This?

This one's a bit hilarious




Any guesses what grade ICCS gave this?
Hint: this is a blatant details coin anywhere else. but not at ICCS.

Wear in the hair, scratches on the cheek, the "6" has been hit, cleaned, and environmental damage on the Rev. I'd say I would give it an XF-40, but maybe ICCS gave them an AU.

I'm amazed, for lack of a better post.

No I don't, nor would I.
That's among the worst ones I've seen yet.

Technically it's an AU/UNC leaner (would have to see it in hand) but blatantly a no grade details/cleaned coin.

Calling it a FIVE? Absolutely unreal. I thought my own experience with abysmal ICCS grading took the cake but nope. That one takes the cake. I mean for thre love of gord, you can still see the old polishing compound jammed into the devices

Ths one likely has been in this holder since just before the Victoria North auction in early 2015. Because of the pedigree and grade, it will probably be in that holder forever.

I saw it in hand then, but do not remember it. I made no catalogue note on it, which means I declined to bid on it. According to iCollector, it did not sell in that auction. Starting bid price of $3,000 CAD plus 15% juice was not met.

Based on the photos below, IMHO the other major TPGs today would grade the coin MS, but probably not red.

Images by Moore Numismatic Auctions and iCollector. Click to enlarge.