The short and simple answer to the question "Why Doesn't America Use The Dollar Coin?" is, "Because the American government refuses to force its people to stop using dollar notes".
Pretty much every other country which, when faced with inflation during the 20th century, replaced their dollar-note-equivalent with a dollar-coin-equivalent, they simply stopped making dollar notes, thus "forcing" everybody to use the coins.
Great Britain, 1983. Stopped issuing £1 notes, started issuing £1 coins.
Australia, 1984. Stopped issuing $1 notes, started issuing $1 coins.
Canada, 1987. Stopped issuing $1 notes, started issuing $1 coins.
Australia, 1988. Stopped issuing $2 notes, started issuing $2 coins.
New Zealand, 1991. Stopped issuing $1 and $2 notes, started issuing $1 and $2 coins.
Canada, 1996. Stopped issuing $2 notes, started issuing $2 coins.
In every single example cited above, there may have been a bit of grumbling - quite a bit of grumbling for Australia in 1988, because nobody liked those tiny little $2 coins - but people simply got used to it. In not one example cited above, did "don't vote for them again, they got rid of a banknote and replaced it with a coin" become an election issue that cost anybody an election.
Are banknotes more "convenient" than coins? Yes. Do coins cost more than banknotes to ship around a country - especially a large country? Yes. Are paper banknotes easier to counterfeit than coins? Also yes. But the benefits to the government bottom line (saving production costs in not having to replace banknotes that wear out after just a few months in circulation) have historically been deemed to be "worth it".
Are there other countries where the highest value coin had the same face value as the lowest-value note, and that country continued to issue both the coins and notes? Yes.
Germany (both West Germany and post-Unification): the 5 deutschmark coin and 5 deutschmark note circulated side-by-side. The coins were rarely seen in circulation pre-1975 when they were still being made of silver, but after 1975, they both circulated. Which one people used, tended to be determined by what people wanted to use them for. 5 mark coins were more useful for vending machines, in an era when vending machines accepting paper money was still essentially unheard of. They even redesigned the old 1960s-era 5 mark note in 1996, just a few years before the deutschmark itself was abolished and replaced by the euro. Germany "made it work".
Switzerland: produced both 5 franc coins and 5 franc notes up until 1952, circulating side by side. The 5 franc coin was quite large (silver-dollar-sized) and made of silver, making them an awkward choice to carry around in bulk, so the paper alternative was understandably popular. The notes were abolished long before the coin composition switched to cupronickel in 1967.
Japan: post WWII, japan issued 100 yen banknotes. They introduced 100 yen coins in 1957, but did not stop printing 100 yen notes until 1974; nearly 20 years of the coins and notes circulating side by side. The 100 yen coins switched from silver to cupronickel in 1967, which seems to have seen a surge in their use.
Later, in Japan: began issuing 500 yen coins for circulation in 1982, alongside the 500 yen note. The note was withdrawn in 1984; it was apparently always the intention to abolish the note soon after the coins were introduced. Again, the driving force seems to have been allowing higher denominations in vending machines, especially as Japan has historically been a much more vending-machine-aligned culture.
So, has any other country actively attempted for 50 years to replace a banknote with a coin, and failed? Um, no, not really. Sorry, America, you're on your own there.
Pretty much every other country which, when faced with inflation during the 20th century, replaced their dollar-note-equivalent with a dollar-coin-equivalent, they simply stopped making dollar notes, thus "forcing" everybody to use the coins.
Great Britain, 1983. Stopped issuing £1 notes, started issuing £1 coins.
Australia, 1984. Stopped issuing $1 notes, started issuing $1 coins.
Canada, 1987. Stopped issuing $1 notes, started issuing $1 coins.
Australia, 1988. Stopped issuing $2 notes, started issuing $2 coins.
New Zealand, 1991. Stopped issuing $1 and $2 notes, started issuing $1 and $2 coins.
Canada, 1996. Stopped issuing $2 notes, started issuing $2 coins.
In every single example cited above, there may have been a bit of grumbling - quite a bit of grumbling for Australia in 1988, because nobody liked those tiny little $2 coins - but people simply got used to it. In not one example cited above, did "don't vote for them again, they got rid of a banknote and replaced it with a coin" become an election issue that cost anybody an election.
Are banknotes more "convenient" than coins? Yes. Do coins cost more than banknotes to ship around a country - especially a large country? Yes. Are paper banknotes easier to counterfeit than coins? Also yes. But the benefits to the government bottom line (saving production costs in not having to replace banknotes that wear out after just a few months in circulation) have historically been deemed to be "worth it".
Are there other countries where the highest value coin had the same face value as the lowest-value note, and that country continued to issue both the coins and notes? Yes.
Germany (both West Germany and post-Unification): the 5 deutschmark coin and 5 deutschmark note circulated side-by-side. The coins were rarely seen in circulation pre-1975 when they were still being made of silver, but after 1975, they both circulated. Which one people used, tended to be determined by what people wanted to use them for. 5 mark coins were more useful for vending machines, in an era when vending machines accepting paper money was still essentially unheard of. They even redesigned the old 1960s-era 5 mark note in 1996, just a few years before the deutschmark itself was abolished and replaced by the euro. Germany "made it work".
Switzerland: produced both 5 franc coins and 5 franc notes up until 1952, circulating side by side. The 5 franc coin was quite large (silver-dollar-sized) and made of silver, making them an awkward choice to carry around in bulk, so the paper alternative was understandably popular. The notes were abolished long before the coin composition switched to cupronickel in 1967.
Japan: post WWII, japan issued 100 yen banknotes. They introduced 100 yen coins in 1957, but did not stop printing 100 yen notes until 1974; nearly 20 years of the coins and notes circulating side by side. The 100 yen coins switched from silver to cupronickel in 1967, which seems to have seen a surge in their use.
Later, in Japan: began issuing 500 yen coins for circulation in 1982, alongside the 500 yen note. The note was withdrawn in 1984; it was apparently always the intention to abolish the note soon after the coins were introduced. Again, the driving force seems to have been allowing higher denominations in vending machines, especially as Japan has historically been a much more vending-machine-aligned culture.
So, has any other country actively attempted for 50 years to replace a banknote with a coin, and failed? Um, no, not really. Sorry, America, you're on your own there.
Don't say "infinitely" when you mean "very"; otherwise, you'll have no word left when you want to talk about something really infinite. - C. S. Lewis






















