tintin02's Last 20 Posts

tintin02

New Member

United States

21 Posts

Posted 05/07/2023 1:54 pm

Quote:
Nice coin, properly graded

Thank you

. May I know how you come to the conclusion that it's properly graded? I'm just new to grading Indian eagle, especially that grading the No Motto series is different than the rest of Motto one. Happy Sunday!

tintin02

New Member

United States

21 Posts

Posted 05/06/2023 12:43 am

Thank you. I think I will contact NGC when I have time haha. Really like the spirit in this community.

tintin02

New Member

United States

21 Posts

Posted 05/06/2023 12:35 am

Woahzahhh. AU-58!! I think it's a PQ coin for this grade. Should I send it to CAC?

tintin02

New Member

United States

21 Posts

Posted 05/05/2023 08:13 am

Hi John!

I think it could be but my inexperienced eyes might be wrong. Waiting more people to chime in.

tintin02

New Member

United States

21 Posts

Posted 05/04/2023 11:47 pm

Some photos if the video is not working. [:D

tintin02

New Member

United States

21 Posts

Posted 05/04/2023 11:30 pm

I tried to recapture the surface. Hope you can see it.

tintin02

New Member

United States

21 Posts

Posted 05/04/2023 11:05 pm

Any thoughts are appreciated!

1951-D Half Dollar. You Vs PCGS

tintin02

New Member

United States

21 Posts

Posted 05/04/2023 10:55 pm

Any thoughts are welcome!

Forum: US Modern Coin Grading

tintin02

New Member

United States

21 Posts

Posted 05/04/2023 10:07 pm

Thank you everyone for your contribution. I'm leaning towards AU-55 but I cannot complain when it's AU-58. I think I have got a decent deal when I paid this for $1350~ slabbed from a dealer.

Should I also contact NGC for their wrong info on the slab? It was labeled as 1907 instead of 1908-D

. Does mislabeled slab carry a premium?
Attached link is a video to showcase its luster.

hAWFCU8coYg

tintin02

New Member

United States

21 Posts

Posted 05/03/2023 9:40 pm

Another coin for your consideration. Wondering what everyone thinks about the grade. All opinions are welcome and thank you in advance!

1908-D Vs 1908 No Motto Indian Eagle $10 In AU Grade Rarity

tintin02

New Member

United States

21 Posts

Posted 05/03/2023 2:19 pm

Do you know where I could get access to reliable price guide that reflects the current market right now?

tintin02

New Member

United States

21 Posts

Posted 05/03/2023 12:35 am

Thank you for everyone's input. Always learning something new everyday.. Really appreciate this community.

1908-D Vs 1908 No Motto Indian Eagle $10 In AU Grade Rarity

tintin02

New Member

United States

21 Posts

Posted 05/03/2023 12:29 am

Hi, everyone. As I'm new to this forum so please delete this post if this question is not appropriate in this forum. I want to ask that for 1908 no motto, even though its mintage is lower, the price of it in au straight graded (ngc/ PCGS) is similar to its 1908-d no motto counterpart. Is this a correct statement or is it vice versa? I have tried to look at past auctions or ebay but I could not get a definitive answer so I hope I could get this clear up on my mind.

Thank you for everyone's time.

tintin02

New Member

United States

21 Posts

Posted 05/02/2023 11:42 am

Is it possible if someone could explain how tarnish could appear on a coin and could it lead to a details grade when it appears on the coin?

tintin02

New Member

United States

21 Posts

Posted 05/02/2023 10:42 am

Quote:
What did PCGS grade it? It looks like serious scratches in that area, like removed graffiti.

PCGS grade it AU-55, I have a chance to look at it through a video. A highly lustrous example. I originally thought it was circulation wear and the black spot was a result of coin ding into the coin field. The spot is actually reflective when moving into different light angle. Now I don't know anymore.

tintin02

New Member

United States

21 Posts

Posted 05/02/2023 04:20 am

I was just looking on the Internet and saw this black spot on the right of the coin which was on an auction months ago. Is the black spot an evidence of old cleaning? How can a black spot cause on a silver coin? And do you think this coin has been cleaned a while ago? Thank you for everyone's input.

Edit 1: upload reverse in case if anyone is curious.

Roosevelt Dime 1946-2022, Including Proof Album Questions

tintin02

New Member

United States

21 Posts

Posted 03/31/2023 4:02 pm

Hi everyone, this album was sent it to me as a gift. I'm keeping it and not planning to sell now but I'm wondering what is the current price sale for an album?

I have looked over ebay and it seems like they're sold for around $300-$500 but the coins are in BU condition (blast white). I grade mine a mix of AU-low BU. Does the price depend on silver dime alone or does clad proof dime carry a premium? Thank you

Forum: US Modern Coins

1915-S Barber Half For Grading Fun Challenge

tintin02

New Member

United States

21 Posts

Posted 01/28/2023 01:01 am

Thank you for everyone's input. The correct answer is: AU58 with CAC approval

The obverse looks like it might have slid in a drawer or lightly circulated a long time ago, resulting luster break yet the surface is fresh. The reverse looks fantastic (could fit into MS scale) with full detail and I cannot even detect any wear on the reverse. Please comment if you detect something that I miss. I'm here to learn.

I think this one looks more eye appealing than those from recent comps and online auctions, even in MS-62 range right now. Is grading inflating right now? I don't regret when paying a premium for this accurately graded AU-58 blazer.

Do you agree with my opinion? Did the result make you surprised? Could it fit into the imaginary AU-63, AU-64 category? Please let me know.