| Author |
Replies: 26 / Views: 3,954 |
Page 2 of 2
|
|
|
|
Valued Member
 Canada
103 Posts |
Isn't that what the ACTUALLY sold for? Or am I reading something wrong? Or is the grade wrong? Feel like I am going in circles here. One part of the equation has to be incorrect, otherwise they have sold for the values shown.
|
|
Valued Member
 Canada
103 Posts |
The key information in my original question (so I did not have to pull out and photograph everything one at a time) was to assume the info on the coins was correct. It literally says "going by the information listed on each coin". I didn't invent any of them, or write any of them, and I have to assume (as I have no reason to doubt) that they are correct.
|
|
Valued Member
Canada
395 Posts |
A certified coin is not what you have and to do that costs money whether its ICCS, CCCS, PCGS, NGC. This going to cost you at cheapest $12 + tax + shipping both ways just to do that. So if you got $15 dollars for your certified coin from ebay after fees you would get less then $13 and since the cert cost more then that you would be losing alot of money every single coin. In addition to that there are only 3-7 coins sold per year so lets just say 1 sells ever 2 months what are the chances are that would be yours. So you would be losing money on every coin and it would still take you years to sell. This is why as I said the coins not made out of silver are face value and the coins made of silver are silver value.
|
|
Bedrock of the Community
United States
94367 Posts |
In the case of the coins you've shown us, that is sadly pretty much the case. 
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
1005 Posts |
 The photos provided are insufficient for grading. If you just want to assume the grades on the holders then you can value them on your own
|
|
Valued Member
 Canada
103 Posts |
Well those last two answers sure help a lot more than previous ones. I assume Frog was stating the grades are wrong. That isn't a "dig at me" at all.... I didn't grade them. If anything it makes me feel bad for my dad, who spent his life doing this, and really everything he collected was only worth the same as the change in his pocket.
This is why I don't collect honestly. It banks on a "future", and the way the world works, that future is FAR from certain. I want to slide in to my coffin with -$8 in the bank, so I know I enjoyed every cent!
|
|
Valued Member
 Canada
103 Posts |
As stated.. I had no reason to doubt the grades. And I did value them on my own, which was contradictory to the face value, I was being told. Yet no one said "the grades are wrong".
Thus the questions @ Llew
|
|
Valued Member
 Canada
103 Posts |
To have something professionally graded, do they always have to be sent off via mail, or are there places you can just walk in to and have it done?
For future reference, if there is something I want to do that with.
|
|
Valued Member
Canada
395 Posts |
You live in Calgary so you would have to mail as you are near no reputable grading companies. You could always try piggybacking on a dealer submission. Right now I see no coins that really need grading from all your posts at the moment.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
1005 Posts |
No one here knows or can possibly if the grades are right are wrong, you did not provide good enough pictures for even a rough guess at any of the grades.
|
|
Valued Member
 Canada
103 Posts |
Again. And for the last time. The OP specifically says to go by what it says. Hypothetically. It literally used those exact words.
No one asked for a grade. At all. It says to assume they are accurate. It was for my information to establish whether I could go by what the site lists. I now see I cannot, and therefore isn't a resource I need to utilize.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
1005 Posts |
You were asking if the grades are wrong, I was trying to help by suggesting better pictures. There's no need to be rude to us, we just want to help you. Quote: I assume Frog was stating the grades are wrong. Quote: Yet no one said "the grades are wrong".
|
|
Valued Member
 Canada
103 Posts |
Rude? I have gone over the top thanking people and trying to be polite.
I guess you can't please everyone.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
Canada
1723 Posts |
Noob,
So I just read this entire thread, I sense a bit of frustration everywhere. I have not read any other topics you may have been involved in so anything I say now is purely based on this thread alone.
You're not being rude from what I can see. Just a bit of confusion that you're trying to get clarified regarding the grade to sold prices and a bit of misunderstanding from some posters that are trying to help but may have accidentally skipped over a "key " word in your statement by accident. No biggie, everything's good.
First off, based off your OP of assuming The grades in the pictures are true, the price Values that you found would be correct. That many coins WERE sold around that amount but just because x-amount sold around that price doesn't mean that is what the market demands. Hundreds of coins from those years are sold not just 10 or 15 or 25. Unfortunately like some others have mentioned, most of the coins you have there would really only fetch say $3 for non silver and maybe $4-7 for silver. And that would take some time before finding a buyer. It would sell eventually but I'm not sure you're wanting to invest that time. That's your decision obviously.
Second, IMHO even if you could easily submit there coins for grading. Due to the fact that these are no where considered high value coins, it would NOT be worth your time or money to submit them. Again, my opinion.
Final, there are different kinds of collectors out there. Some are investment collectors while others just may like holding coins, others like myself just like to hold and appreciate the history behind them. To each their own as they say. Your dad never wasted his time if he at least enjoyed the hobby. Perhaps he had a side hope that in time they may appreciate it value and one day they will, just won't be in our lifetime.
Hope this helps a bit. I know a lot of this is repeat from other responses. Cheers!
Edited by samsnate 04/27/2019 9:28 pm
|
|
Valued Member
 Canada
103 Posts |
Thanks you Samsnate. Sorry for the delay in responding. I just had my two new puppies arrive, and while they are awesome, I've been swamped and sleep deprived for a while now.
I have to say I love your response. And I'm almost embarrassed to say that it almost made me cry a little. I miss my dad, and I appreciate the alternate way of viewing his hobby. He truly did enjoy it, and I guess your right. In that light it wasn't a waste of time. I prefer to think of it that way, so thank you for making me realize that. It's not all about the money for me..... I just have no one to pass it on to, so the value becomes more important than it may be to my brothers and sister.
Have a great day! :)
|
|
Page 2 of 2
|
Replies: 26 / Views: 3,954 |
Page 2 of 2
|