Trader Dollar And Seated Liberty

i think you are mixing up morgan and Trade dollars, can you post a pic?

A sharp eye, Adam!

As Adam pointed out, some of the combinations of date and mintmark that you have designated for these " Trade dollars" you found don't exist within the Trade dollar series, such as the 1885 CC and 1882 S. However, these combinations are found within the Morgan dollar series.



And as David pointed out, as excited as I was (and as most of us would be) to think you might have stumbled upon such a rarity at that price, it's difficult to be confident in the authenticity of a coin bought in such a manner. I wouldn't do anything further with this lot of silver dollars until you go about authenticating your purchase.

I told the guy at the store to check them / validate and he did
They are defiantly silver . For if they are silver made replicas I am not sure but the guy wouldn't make me an offer if was
He seemed very eager to buy it



The other side

I have to agree, the texture is off and the details are very indistinct.

i can guarantee that coins 1,5,7,9,and 11 are all fake/fantasy pieces, I'm not sure about the others, I need to compare both yours and actual ones graded by pcgs.

Yes, many fakes were/are made out of silver as well.

I can see the seams on most of those coins so the ones you can see the seams on are definitely fake, and that puts the rest in a high percentage of being fake as well. Not to mention we all know the 1885 is a fake because they didn't make any Trade dollars after 83 so I would go back to that jewelery store and tell them you found out the coin you sold them is fake and purchase it back before you see yourself on the news and have the police knocking on your door. If you think it won't happen just look in the paper and on tv from the pawn shops that have gotten taken like this, they have their picture and stories in the paper asking for information to call the police so they can press charges. I am sure a jeweler has video cameras so you will probably see your picture on the news soon if you do not do the right thing. These are not contemporary counterfeits so there is probably no silver ion them at all so you couldn't even sell them for silver content until you have them essayed but I am willing to bet not a single one has any silver in them at all, they are just layered with it if they pass the silver test. The fakes that are usually silver was made to circulate beside the originals and these aren't any of those. all of these are newer counterfeits not any of them are contemporary.