1896 Italian Coin | Eritrea

quote:

---

I am confused with this item, and I have a few questions.

1. What is it?
2. Is it real? Or is it a reproduction?
3. Value of a real one? Value of a reproduction?
4. Metal content possibly?

---

1. Italian Eritrea, 5 lire / 1 tallero 1896, KM# 4.

2. I'm always reluctant to condemn a coin based just on a couple of pics, but I'd have to lean towards reproduction. It's very weakly struck up, and the fine details you'd expect to be present (in the hair, coat of arms, etc) are absent, in a way not consistent with simple wear.

3. Real ones in that condition (and the details are so weakly struck, it's hard to judge condition) CV $300-$600. Fakes? From China by the boxful, $1 each.

4. Real ones should weigh 28.125 grams of .800 fine silver. A fake might be silver, but the typical alloy from China is a high-lead, silver-free alloy.

I'd have to agree also it's a reproduction probably made in China.

Yes, there seems to be a similar tell-tale color with these pressure-cast pieces, and surely weight would determine a composition difference. I've looked at several of pressure-case fakes at dealers who kept them to compare to authentic coins. Aside from the actual details or lack thereof on the coin, there's always a notable difference in the surface, where the pressure-cast fakes show minute bubbles and pitting that would never be seen in a struck coin. As long as these fakes are made the same way, detection should be easy upon close inspection since there's no way to fake a struck surface except by recreating the original process. I'm not an expert in these matters...but I have educated myself a bit