They look relatively spot free but hard to tell if they have been cleaned or not. I agree the 1927 looks a bit more original. I would love to see a close up of the 1927 reverse area where it says "2 1/2 dollars", if possible. Jimbucks is correct that these don't carry a premium at the mid grades. Really only at mid-MS is where they start to go up. I'd remove them from the holders and try to get clearer pics (because 2.5 indians are my favorite series and I always want to see more). =)