| Author |
Replies: 8 / Views: 576 |
|
|
New Member
United States
41 Posts |
 While I've been busy building out version 4 [ https://goccf.com/t/481576] of my AI coin-sorting robot, I've gained a lot of experience creating 3D models in Fusion. An interesting thing I've noted over the years is the variety of opinions on slab box designs. There was a lot of anticipation about what design CAC would go with. Now that I have a 3D printer, I'm wondering if there is a new design that would make the lives of collectors and dealers easier.  I'm looking to design and test new layouts based on the community's needs. For folks who are open to sharing their feedback, I'll ship out these prototypes for free. Some questions on top of my head - What are the biggest issues with today's designs, and how are you addressing them now? - Are you more of a collector or dealer? - Ideally, how many slabs should a box hold to best meet your needs? - Would you want your boxes to be personalized, like with your company name or name? - Interested in having me ship out a prototype for you to test out? Edited by DanscoAlbumDude 01/11/2026 02:56 am
|
|
|
|
Moderator
 United States
15384 Posts |
I don't have an opinion on the slab holders, but look forward to seeing where this goes. 
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
1227 Posts |
I don't have a ton of slabs but a few dozen. I and have never seen a slab holder in person, but with that said I would think a very important thing to me would be that the surface of the box would be designed so that it would not scratch the surface of the slabbed coins. Ie interior felt or similar metrical material. Just my thought. As far as how bid or how many would depend from owner to owner. Good luck with this project.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
613 Posts |
For me, the frustration begins with the fact that NGC boxes do not adequately accommodate PCGS slabs and vice versa. The result is that slabs either don't fit properly or not at all (or slip to the next slot). Secondly, if you do mix slabs, the top of the box no longer fits. As for size, the max should be twenty to help both with weight and collection size. I am a collector not a dealer.
|
|
Moderator
 United States
187472 Posts |
Very interesting. I am quite happy with my Lighthouse box, but I am sure there is always room for improvement. 
|
|
Valued Member
Italy
284 Posts |
Very cool, I'll brain dump a bunch of thoughts below.
I only do slabs and own a lighthouse "fancy" slab box (the one with 50 slots). It fits both PCGS and NGC just fine. I like the cool design but at the same time worry a bit that the materials used for the inserts might not be 100% safe (looks like they are glued and might come apart as the years go by). It would be nicer if the slots were more high-quality.
Would be cool if I could write what the box is for on top (professionally, that is) like: World Silver Crowns, Gold Yada yada, etc.
If you print in plastic, the inserts are gonna scratch the plastic.. that'd be troublesome. I'd prefer a softer material than the slab plastic (and archival safe, obviously). Also, plastic is ugly, I would not use a 3d printed box. I'd want a wood or metal exterior finish.
While the box is half-empty, it's possible to place some silica packs in the slots but once the box will be full, I will need to resort to place them above, which is ugly. Would be cool to have a place underneath the slots to lay flat some packs (maybe a drawer or similar, which would also allow to replace them without removing all slabs. This extra space could also be fitted with a temp/hum sensor to see all is good inside.
The lighthouse design is fine but thinking in the future, it won't scale well. What if I end up with many boxes? Do I stack them on top of each other? place them side by side? That will take so much place. A composite system might be more useful (like you can LEGO it to add more slots). Like 4 rows x 5 and then you can clamp a bunch of them together?
Removing the coins for viewing is a bit of a pain. How cool would it be if it were possible to lift and show up to x amount of slabs without removing and placing on a different tray? Kinda like an old disk player loading system. Likewise it would be nice to have a way to know which slab is which without randomly pickup up slabs (numbering system, way to write what is what on the inside of the lid, etc).
Cheers
|
|
New Member
 United States
41 Posts |
So I ended up abandoning the project to create a new type of slab holder. I got a lot of great feedback from people and I concluded that the current solutions today are adequate enough for most people. Some folks are still facing some odd edge cases but for the most part this problem has been solved. It's great see all the wonderful discussions and ideas and shared. Thanks everyone!
|
|
Moderator
 United States
94636 Posts |
I have all my slabe in the PCGS boxes, but the ANACS and NGC slabs don't fit well (too tall) so the cover will not go in properly. ( really do not want to start paying to have my slabs re done so they are all the same. - so a box that would fit any grading companiy slabs will fit AND have a lid that closes properly would be great (lid for dust control mostly.)
|
|
Moderator
 United States
187472 Posts |
Thank you for the update.  A good reason why I settled on just PCGS—uniformity in the storage box I chose.
|
| |
Replies: 8 / Views: 576 |
|