|
This page may contain links that result in small commissions to keep this free site up and running.

Welcome Guest! Registering and/or logging in will remove the anchor (bottom) ads. It's Free!
To participate in the forum you must log in or register. | Author |
Replies: 5,649 / Views: 461,588 |
|
|
|
Pillar of the Community
 United States
3789 Posts |
I think for an investor, who wants to buy and hold, and is looking to make a good positive return on their money, where they enter IS very important. For the investor, identifying where in the cycle and trend PMs are, is going to allow them a safety net in terms of where they enter with their purchases and return on investment.
Blindly buying, based on the fact that one is holding for the long term, while in a downtrend is a bad idea. Throwing good hard earned cash into something that goes lower is not a wise idea when one has other options to grow the money in between.
The other danger is buying silver based on where you think its going. None of us have the power or money to influence where we think silver or gold should go. As a trader, I am beholden to the market. There is no asset where I can think that "x" should be worth this in this amount of time. IF I did that, I would blow up my account, be out of a job and out on the street.
Investing in commodities can be very lucrative. But in a downtrend, unless you are selling it short, or doing intra-day trading on it, investing for the long haul is going to be a very emotionally taxing ordeal and possibly financially draining.
There will be a time where a floor is established. There will be a time when the trend changes. There will be an area where the market says "enough is enough, this is the price where its valued going forward".
Commodities are not like stocks where a yield is paid, they are not a currency where they can be a carry trade, and they aren't like bonds that offer shelter and yield depending on what kind of bond they are.
Finally, today there were ominous signs today for gold and silver besides the price action. Did you catch the headlines from Japan, which is going to embark on their form of QE... and the ECB also is ramping up various forms of QE as well. ALL this QE being announced, even today,,, and gold and silver did nothing but drop.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United Kingdom
548 Posts |
yup7676,
Isn't gold dropping because the Federal Reserve ended their QE? Maybe that's all it takes and it doesn't matter what anyone else is doing.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
1804 Posts |
yup7676 Quote: Investing in commodities can be very lucrative. But in a downtrend, unless you are selling it short, or doing intra-day trading on it, investing for the long haul is going to be a very emotionally taxing ordeal and possibly financially draining. So very happy you informed the fellow CCFers that commodities can be SHORTED. Many (some) investors are not fully aware that you might-can-may be able to sell something you do not have. Albeit a margin is required. The margin is the same on the short side as well as a long position, last time I looked. I personally prefer the short side of trading anything. It is (generally) a faster market, and you get the full advantage, of using fear, panic, ego, greed and ======>HOPE,<====== Thank you yup7676
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
1804 Posts |
FUTURES UP DATE I have been away from commodities too long  The CME offers a MINY and MICRO gold contacts. 10 oz of GOLD -- and 50 oz of GOLD The MICRO 10 oz contract is well in the range of most all hedgers and speculators. 
|
|
Pillar of the Community
 United States
3789 Posts |
@DemarcoBishopp
well, my point was that for a longgggg time now, the rhetoric from PM bugs has been- QE is going to make the PMs explode.
Well, now Japan and the ECB are embarking on some biggg programs. Gold and silver are not responding as the PM bugs would led you to believe.
I circle back to my main point tho- silver and gold are in a big powerful downtrend. The downtrend is a process and it will take its time to play out. In time the downtrend will run out of steam. But its all a process.
@domain555
well I am glad to see someone else here who's into markets or has had experience with them. When I first came here, before I even posted, I was surprised that no one was talking in terms of technicals, and in a trading lingo.
I mean really, by sharing knowledge on how price works, and keeping it super simple (which I have tried so hard, I have tried to keep the charts with simple daily charts showing simple trend lines, not discussing moving averages, BBs, shark/crab patterns, wave counts, etc etc etc etc. You'll notice I try and keep the chart clean, simple and with very little so that attention to be put on price and how it acts) I think we can take the mystery out of the PMs.
I mean what I am doing, is not new, the patterns I see and have learned, shoot, those go back 100 years plus. They repeat over and over and over. It also simple, it is easy to understand price action, all you have to do is open your mind and acknowledge that no matter what one thinks, the market has the final say and if you follow them market, you will have very little pain and frustration.
and yes, those same things, greed, fear, hope, panic, like Jesse Livermore wrote almost 80 years ago, remain here and thats why patterns always repeat, nothing is new, at all in speculating....
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United Kingdom
837 Posts |
Quote: Isn't gold dropping because the Federal Reserve ended their QE? Its funny you ask that question because some reports on line have suggested that .... Quote: the rhetoric from PM bugs has been- QE is going to make the PMs explode.
Well, now Japan and the ECB are embarking on some biggg programs. Gold and silver are not responding as the PM bugs would led you to believe.
I circle back to my main point tho- silver and gold are in a big powerful downtrend. The downtrend is a process and it will take its time to play out. In time the downtrend will run out of steam.  I am shocked by the anergy of the gold and silver market to these QE events , I guess the issue now is... once the downtrend runs out of steam will prices start to rise or will they settle on a new low for while .....thats what might keep some tossing and turning in their sleep at night 
|
|
Pillar of the Community
2087 Posts |
I got out of buying gold in 2008 because of all the financial illiterates who were saying QE is going to create inflation and as a result the Gold price would explode. All of those handicapped people just did not understand the basic economics of the situation. The velocity of money was dropping to levels seen around the time of the 1930s depression and the 1870s-1890s long depression. QE was only put into place to stop the velocity of money going to zero! QE in Europe and Japan is doing the same thing which is in other words fighting deflation. IMHO any one still thinking Hyper inflation is just around the corner needs a brain transplant! ( ie: give chicken little back his brain)
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
4992 Posts |
My general rule is to commit no more than 5-10% of my net worth into commodities and be VERY PATIENT to choose the right entry point. At $16/oz, I think this is an excellent point to enter Silver.
With all investments, the key is to determine true value and ignore the whims (current quotation) of the marketplace. The "all in" cost to produce silver, inclusive of capital investment for mining equipment, is on the order of $24 per ounce. Existing mines can crank out the metal for a production cost of around $10 per ounce but that supply won't last forever certainly not 20 years.
So optimistically we're getting a $24 asset for $16 and, pessimistically, we're getting a fairly priced asset that will almost certainly rise with inflation - due to production costs - and probably much more due to central bank currency manipulation.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
1804 Posts |
If it is true that the end of QE means higher interest rates, then this will lead to higher cost of carry for PMs. Gold, silver etc, pays no interest, and there is also a cost to keep it safe in storage. Higher interest rates = lower PM prices in general, every other things being equal. This is a fundamental issue.  Personally I am a 100% Tech. The price is the summation of all known and unknown commodity issues
|
|
Pillar of the Community
2087 Posts |
Quote: Higher interest rates = lower PM prices in general, every other things being equal. This is a fundamental issue How fundamental? =======> In the late 1970s early 80s every one was saying High interest rates meant higher PM prices. People were buying gold to protect against inflation. ( I recall My first mortgage was regarded as cheap at 19% per annum) Currently Interest rates are ridiculously low...... My wife and I pay under 1% per annum on our floating mortgage in Vienna Austria. I think the inflation rate in Europe has to get to normal level (2-3%) with interest rates at 4-5% before inflation starts to even look like a problem.
Edited by austrokiwi 11/02/2014 1:51 pm
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
1804 Posts |
Quote: ( I recall My first mortgage was regarded as cheap at 19% per annum) I well remember this time. Inflation was running APPROX 1.1% monthly We were flipping one jumbo CD at APPROX 15% at that time. I was fool not to have locked in a 20-30 year Treasury at 12% Worse yet, I could have owned a 20 year striped zero coupon Treasury. 
|
|
Pillar of the Community
 United States
3789 Posts |
Its hard to say what happens whenever this downtrend ends.
It will end at some point. What happens after that, I really dont know. I have seen assets chop around and waste away in a long range for years, I have seen some regain have their value, I have seen a FEW rocket back to highs, tho not historic highs.....
When the downtrend ends, it will be important to keep an open mind, just as one keeps an open mind that it started to fall years ago, instead of fighting it, one has to keep an open mind that eventually the downtrend dies off, and gold and silver attempt to get into some sort of range.
What we do know for sure is any grind up will be very slow, choppy, as every level we encountered on the way down, we will run into on the way up. That will cause the price to stall, drop, and chop.
Patience will once again be needed and time. Time works out things in the markets.
I would be very careful in deciding how to value any commodity thats dropping. That is for the market to decide. Trying to determine the value of silver based on the miners is a losing proposition and nothing but mere guessing. The miners are not very straight forward of what and how they come around on production costs, furthermore, many many many of them hedge their production via currencies, futures contracts and more so unless this is your area of expertise, you are going to have a hard time.
In the end, it is the market place that decides the real value of gold and silver. The market doesn't work on whims. The market is the worlds greatest discounting machine and it works into the future. What it is doing now is what it is expecting and will work out in the future. It is taking the knowns and processing them and displaying via the price action.
That brings me to another point. As a trader, I dont waste my time with thinking about deflation, stagnation, inflation or anything else. It really doesn't matter at all. It means absolutely nothing to me.
It is not my job to "guess" whats coming up. What matters right now, whats leaving clues is the price action. I dont need to waste my time in debating in my mind "what if" or "could be" .... I see it, when price reaches important points, I take action.
In time, we will know exactly why something happened.. but whats more important is taking action when the market is signaling to take action, the "why" will come later and is the least of my worry.
BTW, for those who really want to attempt to dig deep into the miners, both gold and silver, and really hear what is exactly going on, skip the financial media and go right to managements discussion via the reports they by law must file with the SEC.
I highly encourage those who want to learn in detail about the miners to go to sec.gov go to the tab where you enter a companies stock symbol and all their reports are there.
In many of them, in the quarterly report, you will find a section called managements discussion, and there you will find a open, easy to understand discussion of production costs, hedging, and more. you can see right from management what do they plan on doing going forward, etc.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
Canada
576 Posts |
Yup7676...Again I have to say I'm enjoying the discussion here and your wisdom / council. Have you ever considered writing a book? Being a bit of a collector I'd like a signed copy please.
No really, you are well spoken (on paper),you have covered a great deal of information and topics sometimes attacking topics from different directions. I am confident that I have learned items of value during this discussion.
thank you Liverpool Remember, a signed 1st edition would be best.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
3843 Posts |
Silver down another $0.33 to $18.55. Looks like Monday might be another rout.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
606 Posts |
I know people like Yup don't look at behavioral considerations of investing. However, I can't imagine how much silver is sitting on the sidelines from people buying and planning to sell in "20 years." Every year millions of coins join the sidelines and every year mines produce more and more silver.
With changes in film, demand is down and solar finding it can use less and less per panel.
So what happens if as Yup says, the indicators change and the market moves. I think there is a built in ceiling in silver that will always ruin it as a great investment. Obviously this is all in my opinion, but if silver ever hits $40 again, I think you will find people looking to get out and few wanting to get in. How many of you would buy at $40? Not me, I started when it was $20 and would probably quit regardless if it ever went above $25.
|
| |
Replies: 5,649 / Views: 461,588 |
To participate in the forum you must log in or register.
Disclaimer: While a tremendous amount of effort goes into ensuring the accuracy of the information contained in this site, Coin Community assumes no liability for errors. Copyright 2005 - 2026 Coin Community Family- all rights reserved worldwide. Use of any images or content on this website without prior written permission of Coin Community or the original lender is strictly prohibited.
Contact Us | Advertise Here | Privacy Policy / Terms of Use
|
| Coin Community Forum |
© 2005 - 2026 Coin Community Forums |
| It took 0.66 seconds to rattle this change. |
 |
|
| |
| |