1884 S Morgan (Coin received, New Pics)

"it does appear that they are from Florida just like NNC"

If you want proof, do a whois for https://www.nnccoingrading.com and correlate to Centsles' actual name and address. They're the same person. (This is all publicly accessible info).

Very sad....looks like someone let greed get in the way of being an honest coin dealer. It's too bad many people have fallen for their bs and more will do so too.

Actually, that looks considerably nicer than the previous picture.

It might be lightly cleaned, but not that bad really

I'd agree with AU-50 or AU-53 details. There are a lot of small contact marks and it doesn't seem to have any luster. That might indicate it's been stripped of original surface which might cause it to be rejected by the major grading services. If you're willing to gamble, I'd go with PCGS. You'll have to decide whether to crack it out or send it in still in the slab. I think they are more likely to reject the coin if it's in the slab, especially since it's an NNC slab.

For comparison, here's my 1884-S.




This coin has quite a few contact marks and some hairlines, but it does retain considerable luster around the letters and stars. ANACS called this a no-problem AU-55.

Good luck on the cross-over if you decide to go for it!