Numismedia is a little on the high side in my experience. For this coin there's the harsh cleaning issue, the commonality of the date (1833 was a high mintage year in CBH terms), and the fact that this coin is a common variety (R.1, over 1000 known).
I also agree that it's XF details, but the net grade/price would likely (depending on the forum) be lower than VF, and probably more in the VG-F range. I personally would not expect to pay more than $50-65 maximum for it, but there may be those who would pay more.