well, I have to say you definitely upgraded the one you had.
i really like the reverse on this one. although the photos are nice, the lighting in the photos is throwing off too much glare for me to assess the coins surfaces properly.
looks like a small reeding hit on the right elbow which could point to it being banged around a little in a bag at one time. light field marks on the right obv field. A few small ticks on the gown and on the eagle wing horizontal to the A in AMERICA. light strike on the head and olive branches. cant get a good handle on whether its missing luster.
there is a fine line between a really nice AU58 and an MS coin
without photos with less glare I'm going with a decent AU58