A few tidbits about the McKinley Birthplace Memorial Gold Dollars...Tidbit #1The National McKinley Birthplace Memorial Association was created/chartered by the 61st United States ("US") Congress in 1911. Per its authorizing legislation, the Association's objective was to:
"...perpetuate the name and achievements of William McKinley, late President of the United States of America, by erecting and maintaining in the city of Niles, in the State of Ohio, the place of his birth, a monument and memorial building."The commemorative gold dollar proposal to financially support the effort would come later.
For a look at the Memorial, see:
-
McKinley Birthplace Memorial and Museum.
Tidbit #2 Charles E. Barber prepared very different portraits of William McKinley for the obverse of the Birthplace Memorial coin vs. the obverse of the Louisiana Purchase Exposition ("LPE") Gold Dollar.
While both present a left-facing portrait of McKinley, the Birthplace Memorial portrait is far less formal - gone are McKinley's suit and tie (as is any depiction of clothes). The LPE portrait is a formal "head and shoulders" rendering, while the Birthplace Memorial portrait is of the "head and neck" variety.
To my eye, the facial features of the two portraits are similar enough to convince me they are of the same man and to suggest that the overall differences perceived by some are tied more to the style (business attire vs. no attire) of the portraits than anything else.
Obverse Comparison: LPE Gold Dollar vs. Birthplace Memorial Gold Dollar
Tidbit #3The legislation that authorized the McKinley Birthplace Memorial Gold Dollar set a mintage limit of 100,000 coins; the Act did not, however, limit the dates/years for striking the coins. Sales of the coin did not come close to the authorized mintage maximum.
Per US Mint records, 20,000 of the coins were struck in 1916, and 10,000 in 1917 (plus Assay coins in each year). Approximately 10,000 of the coins were returned to the Mint to be melted; the total appears to have been a mix of both dates, but specific melt records for each date are not available. Thus, a net mintage of approximately 20,000 coins resulted (both dates combined).
Note: Different references report different figures; I've used US Mint Records for my reporting.The Issue Price of $3.00 per coin was a significant driver behind the low sales volume - to the surprise of the Memorial Association which believed the coin would be more popular. The lack of sales resulted in thousands of coins being sold at lower bulk prices to dealers, including B. Max Mehl who purchased more than the others.
Tidbit #4The William McKinley Birthplace Memorial (Niles, Ohio) was dedicated on Saturday, October 5, 1917. The primary Keynote Address at the dedication ceremony was given by former US President William Howard Taft. As President, Taft signed the bill that authorized the incorporation of the McKinley Birthplace Memorial Association on March 3, 1911. The Association led the effort to create/construct the Memorial. (See Tidbit #1 above.)
Note: William Taft was President from March 4, 1909, to March 4, 1913.1917 William McKinley Birthplace Memorial Gold Dollar

For other of my posts about commemorative coins and medals, including more classic era Tidbits stories, see:
Commems Collection