I'm glad everyone enjoyed discussing this coin. It's rare to have so many people interested. Coins like this are a lot of fun. The strike/die issues on certain Lincolns make for good conversation.
Take what you will from this thread, the coin is what it is. As interested as you guys are in the 'real' grade, I'm not going to slab this coin. It's fun that you guys are that curious, but really, I'm not taking peoples money to settle the debate. LOL