It's starting to look like SuperDave is right about digital photos exaggerating every little nick. Certainly PCGS didn't see the nicks and hits to be as severe as most posters thought. Many of my slabs seem to have abrasions that are basically invisible to the eye but they show up in the photos. This photo of the slab for example does not show the coin to be nearly as nice as it is.

It may be time to invest in some equipment to improve my photo quality.