Quote:
I've never considered a coin with this few strikes, to be a real coin, rather a novelty. JMHO
IMHO, any coin struck at the mint, even surreptiously, is a coin. Like the notorious 1913 nickel, millions of error coins, minor and major, have found their way into circulation and/or the marketplace.
One of my best finds at a show was a six cent piece. It's a 2000 cent that was partially overstruck on a nickel press. To my knowledge, it's the only one known. Does this error qualify to be a coin? To me, "yes." Others would say "no." To each his own. Still, it's certainly marketable as a coin, is it not?
Many coins are "novelties" in their own right ... errors, counterstamps, love tokens, envased coins, etc. I personally don't feel a need to deny these items coin status. Of course, given damaged planchets and other alterations, many such novelties won't fit conveniently in albums/holders that mainstream collectors covet. To me, this aspect and the rarity of such novelties is what has long drawn me to collect them.
Vive la difference! 


Edited by ExoGuy
06/23/2026 3:18 pm