Will PCGS Cross An Segs Coin?

Give PCGS a call and ask. They will probably say no but it doesn't hurt to ask. If you are concerned about cracking out the coin then most grading companies will do that for you as long as you make it clear it is being submitted raw.

Incorrect. A quick search of their message boards states they also accept SEGS and PCI graded coins. PCGS will accept any holder. Again, just call to confirm before trying to crossover "off" label holders. In the past PCGS explicitly stated they would take any holder and perform a courtesy "crack-out" if you want them to grade it as raw but I don't see that right now.

Thanks guys! I hadn't see the updates to this post until just now... I really don't want to try and crack it out of these holders... I don't mind them only accepting them as "raw" because the grades given by SEGS were BS! (That's not a grading acronym, it's a bad word) I will give PCGS a call about it before I submit them

By whom?

PCI is a joke - the current incarnation has graded perhaps 10,000 coins since they resurfaced in 2012. And their grading over the years before that bankruptcy has been up and down. Oh, yeah and before 2012, they were engaged in fraud since the boiler room SELLING their "3rd party" coins was owned by the owner of PCI.

SEGS - well, SEGS has fans and detractors, with some people feeling they do well on certain series and less well on others.

The market has put ANACS and ICG in a separate tier from PCGS and NGC. You can call it 1.5, 2.0 or whatever...

I have not handled a SEGS coin in many years. The best one I ever had was an 1848-C $2.50 gold piece that they graded MS-63. It so happened that a dealer I knew also had an 1848-C quarter eagle in a PCGS MS-63 holder. The PCGS coin was a little better, but the price difference was huge. The SEGS coin cost $6,000; PCGS coin was $20,000.

I sold the SEGS coin for a $500 mark-up to one of the big coin companies, who I am sure cracked it out of that holder.

For the little guy who doesn't know any better, however, they don't know that one MS-63 to not the same as another MS-63. That's why SEGS can be dangerous if you don't know how to grade.

I should mention that 95+% of my SEGS, PCI & ANACS are error coins, where the type of error is more Important then the grade itself..

15 years ago it could easily cost more for NGC or PCGS certification then the error coins value..

I guess I'm comparing and ..

Sure they will cross it, not as a 62, you would have to do a "cross at any grade" and they will happily put it in a PCGS slab at the grade they feel it deserves. If you specify a minimum of MS-62 since that is what is on the holder it will just come back "Will not cross".

They do crossover SEGS. My best crossover ever was SEGS 09-s vdb ms 65rd to PCGS ms65 rd! Set min as RB ms64 and was blown away they crossed it!