Catalog values are usually a joke in my experience. See how long it takes to get the Charlton catalog value of $15 for a 1938 Canada nickel in EF-40 or $5 for any KG VI Canada cent in EF-40. I suspect you'll be waiting a long, long time. I recently sold a 1922 Canada 5 cents graded ICCS MS-63 on
ebay for $51. The catalog value was $175. I got just $70 for a 1895 Large cent graded ICCS MS-62 RB which has a catalog value of $250.