So Far I've searched 3 boxes of nickels. First box was all new coins 2001-2012 with only 1 2000. (I learned my lesson on what to look for so hopefully it won't happen again.) Second Box I found 71 1981 and earlier with 8 young elizabeth II and the oldest was 1958. The third box has been the most interesting so far. Two of the rolls were actually pennies - but they were shiny and mostly new (only 2 1996 and earlier). Found 101 1981 and before including 1956, 1957, 1959, 1961, 1962 and a dime.
I'm going to open an account at TD because they told me if I have an account I can use their coin counting machine for free. That way I won't have to re-roll everything before bringing it back :).