I'm really surprised by these gradings.
I would have graded the heritage coin as GF or F18, and your coin about the same.
I thought of looking at others, which also seem to me to be overgraded,
eg http://www.mcsearch.info/ext_image.html?id=930879
graded AU (and I thought AEF)
and http://www.mcsearch.info/ext_image.html?id=930878
graded EF (and I thought GVF/AEF).
Probably, I'm too conservative and I need to regrade my coins upwards.
I would have graded the heritage coin as GF or F18, and your coin about the same.
I thought of looking at others, which also seem to me to be overgraded,
eg http://www.mcsearch.info/ext_image.html?id=930879
graded AU (and I thought AEF)
and http://www.mcsearch.info/ext_image.html?id=930878
graded EF (and I thought GVF/AEF).
Probably, I'm too conservative and I need to regrade my coins upwards.























