Re-Slabbing A Coin --- Need Advice

Save yourself the headache of a possible return and mention the crack as well as including a photo of it. An honest, accurate description of the slab is the right thing to do, IMO.

I would agree with the previous two posts. If you are going to sell it as-is, definitely mention the chip!

Personally, I would have no problem buying a cracked or chipped slab if I planned on cracking out the coin but if I wanted to keep it in the slab, I would want the plastic to be in perfect condition.

There is always some nutjob out there waiting to accuse a seller of swapping out a coin when they see a cracked slab even if the damage is only superficial, not worth the hassle with an expensive coin IMO. An MS-63 Morgan widget is one thing(who would swap out one of them?) but an MS-63 Indian with 30-40x the value of the previously mentioned widget is another matter entirely.

@Henry M Smith

He is not cracking the coin out and resubmitting it for grading. He is talking about having them "recase" it in a new style holder. All they will do is crack the slab, take the coin out, and put it in a new slab (and hopefully not damage the coin in the process)

Here is a picture of the slab and the chip. As I said, it's not big, but (IMHO) should be identified.