Common Indian Head Cents Value By The Roll?

Depends on the years. If they are mostly post-1889 I'd say you should be able to get them for $0.50 to $0.75 each if you buy them in bulk. I go to a lot of estate auctions and have gotten common date Indian Head cents for less than $0.50 each while at other times people go crazy and pay over a buck each and sometimes two. It depends on your end goal, are you looking to buy them to flip or for your collection? If you are looking to profit on them you need to buy them really, really cheap.

Maybe a coin dealer in your area would sell you some at wholesale prices if they really want to get rid of them and have too many in their inventory.