cipster, I remember your S-184 - I liked that coin a lot as it had nice detail and even surfaces.
In the meantime, I think I have found the S-163 which shares #1 place in the CC with a coin in the ANS. It was the Noyes plate coin, sold by Goldbergs in 2009 as part of the Holmes Collection, lot 298. A superior and beautiful coin graded (as EFlargeCents mentioned) VF30.