The top piece called "a potty dollar," and I think they carved them out from Trade dollars in latter part of the 19th century. Trade dollars lost their legal tender status and were only worth their melt value in those days, which was less than a dollar.
The second is an early counterfeit that was made to fill the hole for a tough coin. I'm not very familiar with the "Smith Counterfeits," but it seems like they have habit of getting pulled from auctions.
The second is an early counterfeit that was made to fill the hole for a tough coin. I'm not very familiar with the "Smith Counterfeits," but it seems like they have habit of getting pulled from auctions.


















