There is no way either of those coins could be Proof pieces. The surfaces are not close to looking like Proofs or even P-L. I wish I had a photo to show you, but I have only one old Proof gold coin in my collection, and it's a gold dollar. I sold a couple when I was dealer, but unfortunagely I didn't grab pictures. Here's the gold dollar.

And here is an 1882 gold dollar which is a Proof-Like, not a Proof.


And here is an 1882 gold dollar which is a Proof-Like, not a Proof.























