Yet Another Forum Game - Numismatic Go Fish!

2 points.

OK this round is over.
I just want to say Dorado posted 60 coins. 90 points
Pepactonius posted 27 coins 69 point

What would be the point of anyone playing this game?
It seams like you two are play amongst your self's
That's no fun for anyone.
And lets make it fun again.
P.S. Pepactonius Very nice coins.

Dorado your up

Congratulations to Dorado on this hard-won triumph.

My Two Cents...

Stipulate that each player only posts their best coin for the theme, not every coin they have that matches it. Score points based on elements that match the host's example.

I by no means meant to upset anyone.
Lets just make the game more challenging.
And more fun for more people to play.

I don't think Dorado will be providing a new challenge.

@keith12

I suppose I started this, or at least exacerbated it with my indecision. In all likelihood, Dorado was the winner of my previous challenge. However, because of complaints and my own remorse, I attempted to give the game a little boost by declaring you the winner. What I wrote about representing my intentions most closely is true, so it wasn't a random choice. I knew others would not appreciate that decision, though.

Ultimately, your challenge was no different! It was still a cumulative points, post as many coins as you can event. I'm not sure what you expected to happen. Dorado rightfully won, so I don't think your additional comments after announcing the winner were needed. Like I said, those of us who have photographed our collections and/or are willing to image coins specifically for this challenge should not be at a disadvantage.

I would also encourage others to play even knowing you won't win. How many times have you seen others, including me, post something for "participation points?" It doesn't take much effort and adds to the variety.

I think jbuck may have to either post a challenge himself or declare another winner so that this game can move forward. Hopefully, Dorado will continue to participate.

That's... a bit restrictive.
In particular, I think it actually disallows my planned idea, which means that, if I ever win, I might have to resort to the "random coin from my collection" method again.

(Approximate context of my complaint: this rule, as stated, appears to disallow themes where it is at least theoretically possible to do better than the host's example - think "post your [one] coin with the most X" where the host's example doesn't actually have that many X.
In other words, about the only remaining option will be something along the lines of "here's a listing of all the design elements on this coin/token/round, 1 point for matching each of them", which is just boring with a different way.)