What's Your Grade On This Raw 1920 Maine Centennial

Beefed - that sure doesn't look like your typical buy.

Technical Grade 53. Eye Appeal 5/10. I'm sure it's nicer in hand given what you normally find.

I've seen better strikes that bring up more of the shield.

The interesting thing about this coin is the lack of wear. I did an overlay of this coin on top of my 65, and there is pretty much no wear on it. The luster is not there though, so I'm thinking about sending it in to be conserved? It's somewhat of a confusing coin to me. It has been stored in a cellophane wrapper in a small manila coin envelope since probably about the 50's (that's the date on the other commems from the owner), and it says the owner bought it in 1925.

If nothing else, I'm going to have my guy at my LCS take a look at it.

It looks AU from the pics but if the OP is seeing MS details in hand - as mentioned ? Weak strike vs maybe dipped too harshly or improperly? Idk, but they are plentiful for a raw album, so waiting for the right coin shouldn't be too painful. My subjective eye appeal meter is 'if it doesn't make me feel like a kid at Christmas', I will probably end up selling later, or finding a replacement.