Well, if it helps any, my "D" part of the set also looks just a bit more 'proofy' than the "P" coins.
Not much of a difference, but the "D" dollar does have more of a silver-ish hue than the "P". By no means do the Philly coins look bad in any way, but you are right about the slight difference.
Mine are still in the plastic cards. Is it possible the difference is due to a variance of the plastic and not the coins? I also have this year's dollar coins from Mint rolls and they ("P" & "D") are similar.
On the other hand, many of the Denver quarters I've picked up in change the past year or two always seem a little nicer (shinier/cameo) than any Philadelphia coins I find.
Not much of a difference, but the "D" dollar does have more of a silver-ish hue than the "P". By no means do the Philly coins look bad in any way, but you are right about the slight difference.
Mine are still in the plastic cards. Is it possible the difference is due to a variance of the plastic and not the coins? I also have this year's dollar coins from Mint rolls and they ("P" & "D") are similar.
On the other hand, many of the Denver quarters I've picked up in change the past year or two always seem a little nicer (shinier/cameo) than any Philadelphia coins I find.



















