1999-2000 Millennium Coin Help.

Excellent that is the answer I am looking for. I do go to coins and Canada often and other sites but I get a variance in values. I also get a variance in values between what people sell for VS book values.

I will keep several sets for myself and roll the rest.

Any advice on the 125 year Canada anniversaries 25cent collection? Some coins are boasting a $19.00 value at Canada and Coin currency.

Why are these coins worth so much from that site? Is it like Real Estate, the values are more subjective in which the value is based on 'what ever someone is willing to pay'?
I also see ebay sellers, selling coins far above there value from coins and Canada site so now I am more confused than ever!

Thanks again for your advice.

Same with 1992 25 cent's, huge production, minimal upside, except for a few errors or very high grade coins.

On the coins and canada site you see a section that says "Auction Prices", this is what "graded" coins are actually selling for on ebay. "Graded" means certified by certain 3rd party companies (ICCS, CCCS, NGC, PCGS, ANACS are generally the more reputable ones), which usually costs $7-$50. Grading is not a necessity, but can help make a sale easier online (not always). This makes many coins un-economical to grade.

The basic listed prices you see in the "Price Guides and Values" section is what we refer to as "catalog" or "trends" pricing. There is a lot disagreement as to how accurate these prices are, see some of the other threads in this part of forum around trends/catalog pricing. Some would argue these prices reflect the true value of the coin, while others believe they are unrealistic, inflated values. I generally think these prices are overestimated by 30%-60% in most cases. When you look at regular auction prices, this generally holds true. Some set a high price to give them space in negotiating.

Remember there is a huge difference between what people ask and what something sells for, I always recommend using actual auction prices. For most coins 1968+, you can sell Mint State coins for 2-5x face, but you will not likely have a huge volume. For example, I sell some coins from 2010+ on ebay for 2-5x face (basically enough to make it worthwhile and cover transaction costs), but only sell 1-2 per month. For example I'll list a 2014 loonie for $3+shipping, no real profit, but hopefully can help someone can fill out their collection.