2000 P & 2000 D Sacagawea Dollar Re-Grade?

I've seen SGS MS70s that were not even MS. Especially Morgans, seen many sliders in MS70 SGS slabs. Gallery grading too.

PCGS and NGC at the top tier TPGs, then there is ANACS and ICG. If it isn't one of those treat it as a raw coin.

To expand on this NGC only lets you cross PCGS slabs. PCGS will let you try to cross any slab you want but when dealing with basement slabs it is best to remove the coin and send it in raw, especially since there is a 0% chance that would grade MS 70 at PCGS.

There's really nothing gained having the coins in that slab, if anything it's actually a negative to most people. Regardless of what I was going to do I would remove the coins and put it in a 2x2 or something like that.

You've already lost about $13, quit while your behind and don't sink any more money into them.

to the Community!

there's just no way the coin is actually MS 70 considering of the 10,000 + examples graded by NGC or PCGS, none have graded above MS69. It's just about impossible that SGS got it right.

SGS is not a real third party grading company, it is a seller on ebay self-slabbing their own inventory as all MS70 which, of course, is impossible in the real world. In actuality your coin probably grades in the MS63-65 range like most fresh from the roll coins do. the coins cost $1 and probably worth a dollar also each, the holder maybe cost him $3.00 from China, so maybe he's got $8.00 into it and sold the pair for $16, not a total rip off but still more than it's worth at possibly $2.00 per raw coin on ebay.

If they were legitimately graded MS70 coins each one would likely sell somewhere about $4000.00 since that what MS69 gets for people for their registry sets.

if they were legit MS-70 they'd be one of a kind and worth tens of thousands of dollars, and not sold for $16.00 for the pair even back in 2000.

Good/bad? you could have lost a lot more money on this than $16.00 (or in your case about $12.00 in overpaying). you didn't do too bad considering how it could have went.
but they just aren't MS70 and won't get anywhere near that if you sent it for grading from an actual third party grading company.

actual grade likely of MS63-MS65 and might be $2.00-$6.00 per coin if you could find a buyer for them at those grades, and they looked nice and BU shiny. like I said you didn't grossly overpay but they aren't MS70 as they are represented to be.

It could be much worse if he had had his friends bid up his auctions to juice you on the price let's say and get you into that hundreds or thousands category where legitimate MS70 examples really belong.

SGS has been out of business for several years now. But there are still a lot of their basement tier slabs out there on the market.