This oldtimer grades #1 as VF and #2 as XF. The surface issues, environmental, on #2 might cause it to be valued as a lower grade, say the equivalent of a Fine or VF. That said, #2 does appear to have a repunched date which would add a modest amount to its value; thus, XF overall. Just my
Two Cents worth ...
P.S. - These Civil War era coins were the first to mention God ... historic and intrinsic value therein!