Two things to note about the example labeled as a "modern reproduction" on that page, DVCollector, which relate to the two examples here. First, the top of the lower serif of the "S" appears horizontal on the reproduction, and angled on SmallEagle's coin. Second, the bitemark out of the right serif of the "A."
Aside the stroke of the "S," which is a smoking gun to begin with.
Looks like the OP seller ended the auction, hopefully for the right reasons. Their Feedback was excellent, and they're a coin specialist, so I'm inclined to be optimistic.
