Need Help. Wondering If I Got A Fake Graded Coin

Without a pic it's going to be very hard to help out. Oh should be able to upload photos from your phone.. Many members, as well as myself do.

But for starters.. What company slabbed the coin? What's the coin? And year, mintmark and the given grade? What's the certification # on the slab? Do you think the coin is fake, or just the slab it's in? And finally why do you believe its fake?

Edit** nevermind.. Lol, awaiting pics from SsuperDdave...

He's not on the forum, and I'm leaving for an hour or two. Here, while you're waiting:

Huh, I wonder why your phone didnt work? O well, doesn't matter. No problem, a pic would definitely be a better help anyways. I only asked those things as often people are cautious about giving there private email addresses on an open forum, but for a moderator with a site email it's much better..

I still a curious as to why you believe it's fake though, that would still be helpful info even with the pics, as well as I would help others to learn what to watch for. Did you go to the NGC site and check the certification number? Or does the slab and/or coin just look totally off to you?

I'm just wondering why someone would fake a common 1896 MS-63.. It's like a $60 coin, there's really no price jumps until you get to MS-65, 66 and a huge jump for 67.. I could see the potential profit in faking a 67 slab but wonder why if someone was trying to make money by counterfeiting a slab they would put the money into faking a common date and slab it as a 63. You get what I mean? And again, your observations as to why you believe it's a fake slab would help others to learn what to look for.

And I'm sorry, where were my manors, I didn't even notice it was your first post... So !

Looking on ebay . Seems Lots of the slabbing have different details on them . This slabbing is identical to the one mines in
http://item.mobileweb.ebay.com/view...50809133492#
Once superdave posts the pics for me it will probably be easier to authenticate

Ron - yes that is correct . No photo is available though on the site but the info pops up

I see no real reason to believe it's anything but a clerical error. No idea whether the error is in the online listing or the slab - I'm inclined to believe the former - but the pics aren't quite clear enough to form a real opinion of the actual grade.

I absolutely agree with SsuperDdave.. Clerical error. It is definitely known to happen, and while not super common, unfortionitely it happens more than we might want to believe.

All of the third party graders have changed their slabs a few times over the years and yours definitely is one that was commonly used by NGC, but you will see other types as well.

But Noah's idea is definitely a good one as well.. It couldn't hurt to call NGC and see what they say.. Even if to only find out if the typo is on their cert page or the slab itself.

But bottom line I'd be inclined to say you have no worries, the coin is most definitely real, as is the slab. Just human error and a typo. Now the only question would be is it actually a 62 or a 63... And again Noah's suggestion of calling NGC may be able to help out with that.