This coin will get a Genuine holder at any
TPG. It's an AMAZING find!
I have been lucky enough to own or broker 6 different examples of this coin. An AU58 in a PCGS holder that I sold on Telerade 18 months ago fetched a record price at $4100. But prices have slipped very quickly. This coin has come out of the woodwork with the known population more than doubling in the last 24 months.
Most recently I sold a PCGS AU58 example in May, I accepted $2000 in a partial trade deal. I probably could have easily realized $500 more, but it was a simple and quick deal.
I feel your coin (if slabbed in a PCGS holder as "Genuine, AU Details) would fetch somewhere in the $700 to $1200 range. There is too few "problem" coin sales recorded to give a more specific value. It's possible it could bring more, but impossible to know until it's offered.
If you'd like some help marketing this coin and realizing strong market value, just shoot me an email.
On the outside chance that you're near Chicago in the next 10 days, we'll be attending the
ANA show most days.
Congratulations on a once-in-a-lifetime find! Best wishes in how you proceed.
-Chris & Charity Welch
LiveanDieVarieties