Quote:
I prefer to be part of something greater than something weaker.
I prefer to be part of something greater than something weaker.
@scott7721 -
This debate goes back 250 years - colonists debated for many years about whether we should have a strong, centralized government. Our first central government, organized around the Articles of Confederation, was far weaker than the one we have today. In fact, that weakness led to its demise a few years later. Then came our Constitution, which created a stronger cental government - with powers to tax etc - but it too was far from perfect. The States immediately drafted and ratified 10 Amendments with the power to add more over time. The Constitution is a great compromise, as are each of the Amendments. Few of us are happy with all of them. Most of us would happily revoke a few Amendments given the chance. To each our own.
To clarify my earlier statements, I don't oppose a strong Federal government, I oppose an abusive Federal government. That's a government that abuses the powers granted to it by the constituent States that created it. The Federal government was created by the States, its only powers are those granted to it by the States. However, 200+ years, 27 amendments, and thousands of laws later, I think the Feds have granted themselves more power than necessary to govern. They do so with case law and Supreme Court rulings that oftentimes don't consider States' powers. To me, that is a problem.
I'm glad to live in a country where we can have these discussions without fear of retribution, and I'm very glad to hear your opinion, even if we disagree.
And I'm very glad the Mods haven't shut down this thread for all the politicking in here.
Edited by jeffbuckes
09/16/2022 3:46 pm
09/16/2022 3:46 pm























