Thank you, Will, for your insights here. I'm trying to get something buttoned down with regards to this supposed specimen shilling https://www.noble.com.au/auctions/lot/?id=348087 (formerly part of this set https://www.noble.com.au/auctions/lot?id=188304 ) which, as I have learned, was slabbed by PCGS sometime early in 2016 (see https://numisbid.com.au/itm/94470/A...men_Shilling ). When I pressed the former auction house about "MS" and "SP" designation, their response was, and I quote, "...The coin is in an older PCGS slab, pre-dating the SP designation introduced in 2015. Before this, coins were designated either MS or PR, with no differentiation for specimen coins..." I found this is a bit odd, especially given that the coin was sold as a raw, uncertified item in November 2015, and to my knowledge had not previously been encased in a holder.
Edited by frank wasson
07/31/2025 4:33 pm
07/31/2025 4:33 pm





















