Whenever I find a wheatie, a pre-1960 nickel or a similarly interesting coin in my change, I place it into a special container. After about a year or so, I'll account for all of these coins and place them into coin tubes or other holder in my main collection box. (Note: None of these coins came from bank rolls; they are strictly from what was handed to me from a cash register when I made a purchase somewhere.)
Here is my latest haul. Lesson to be learned: good, collectible coins are still out there!
(Note: sorry that the photos aren't of better quality.)



LINCOLNS
Bottom row: 1920, 1929, 1936, 1937, 1938 (2)
Second row: 1941-D, 1946-D
Third row: 1940 (3), 1941 (5), 1943 (3), 1944 (5), 1945 (4), 1946 (3), 1948 (3), 1949
Fourth row: 1951-D, 1952-D (2), 1955-D (3), 1956-D (6), 1957-D, 1958-D
Fifth row: 1951, 1953-D, 1955 (3), 1956 (3), 1957 (2), 1958
Sixth row: 1968-S (BU!!), 1969-S (2), 1970-S, 1971-S, 1974-S
Seventh row: 1960-S SD, 1972-D Lincoln/Kennedy novelty coin
JEFFERSONS
Bottom row: 1940, 1942, 1946 (4), 1947 (2), 1968-S (2), 1970-S (3)
Second row: 1954-D, 1956-D
Third row: 1952 (2), 1954, 1955, 1956, 1957-D (2), 1958-D, 1959-D
Fourth row: 1944 Mercury, 1964 Roosevelt