I know it is hard to tell from the pics, and this is a very worn coin - but after seeing 30-40 of the 09-S's, there were two of these coins out of the batch. Both of them pretty much the same, the tail feather detail in the pic from the CPG is gone on these coins, and the mint mark is a little more worn. I was just glad to find SOMEthing out of the ordinary ! That little book sure makes looking alot more fun ! Thanks for the opinions ... More to come.......